Ask The Makeup Diva -  answers to your toughest makeup and skin care questions


Get The Diva
Delivered Free

home | subscribe | ask | past questions | meet the diva | search

Ask The Makeup Diva
Welcome to Ask The Makeup Diva™! Our resident expert, The Makeup Diva, answers makeup and skin care questions sent in by readers just like you.

Q: What is a toner, what does it do and when should I use it? What are some of your favorites?

A: Let me start by saying that there are several different ideas about the role of a toner/freshener/astringent in a skin care routine, depending on who you talk to. Women working at a boutique, salon, spa, or cosmetic counter at a department store will probably tell you that a toner is an essential step, that it "balances" the skin, removes any makeup or dirt that your cleanser missed, and "prepares" the skin for moisturizer or treatment.

First, let's clear up the differences are between toners, fresheners and astringents. These terms are often used interchangeably, with "toner" being the most common. Most "toners" are made up of water, skin soothers like aloe or chamomile, plant oils, ingredients to cleanse or draw moisture to the skin, and preservatives. Typically, "fresheners" are alcohol-free while "astringents" are not. Astringents are usually for oily skin and are often designed to fight acne or control oil.

Another option for toners is the addition of treatment ingredients like alpha hydroxy (lactic, glycolic) or beta hydroxy (salicylic) acids, or vitamins. Of all the extras, salicylic acid can be most helpful for blemish prone skin since it penetrates the pores and helps clear out the dead skin cells and bacteria that can cause pimples.

So, do you really need a toner? Based on my experience over the years with hundreds of products in dozens of different lines, I have to say "No". I have never noticed my skin acting more "balanced" or more "prepared", and you should not need a toner to remove makeup or dirt that your cleanser didn't get - you just need a better cleanser. Having said that, there are a few toners that I do like, for specific reasons. Both Peter Thomas Roth Oxygen Mist and Joey New York Calm & Correct Gentle Soothing Toner do a great job at soothing red, irritated skin, while BeneFit Alpha Smooth has just enough lactic acid to lightly exfoliate and help keep the pores clear. (All three are available from

If you decide to add a toner to your daily skin care routine, make it one that really suits your skin and its needs. Always choose something gentle that doesn't dry, strip or otherwise irritate your skin, and don't spend a fortune on something that is basically souped-up water. Here are a few that I like:

Renee Rouleau Bioflavonoid Toner
Burt's Bees Carrot Seed Oil Complexion Mist
Alba Botanica Toner

Get Ask The Makeup Diva Delivered to Your E-mail box Every Week! SUBSCRIBE FREE!

For more great makeup and cosmetic reviews and information also visit Cosmetic Connection.

Got a Question? The Makeup Diva may already have an answer! Search past columns for the answers to your questions.

Copyright (C) - 2003-07 & Inc. ISSN#: 1525-6294